Love! Valour! Compassion!
New Line Home Entertainment (5/16/1997)
Comedy, Drama, Queer Themes/Interest, Romance
In Collection
#17
5*
Seen ItYes
(7/1/2016 Home)
794043494628
IMDB   7.0
108 mins USA / English
DVD  Region 1   R (Restricted)
Anthony Heald
Jason Alexander Buzz Hauser
Justin Kirk Bobby Brahms
John Benjamin Hickey Arthur Pape
John Glover John Jeckyll, James Jeckyll
Stephen Spinella Perry Sellars
Randy Becker Ramon Fornos
Stephen Bogardus Gregory Mitchell
Director
Joe Mantello
Producer Doug Chapin
Diane Conn
Barry Krost
Writer/Composer Terrence McNally
Terrence E. McNally

Gregory invites seven friends to spend the summer at his large, secluded 19th-century home in upstate New York. The seven are: Bobby, Gregory's "significant other," who is blind but who loves to explore the home's garden using his sense of touch; Art and Perry, two "yuppies" who drive a Volvo and who celebrate their 14th anniversary together that summer; John, a dour expatriate Briton who loathes his twin brother James; Ramon, John's "companion," who is physically attracted to Bobby and immediately tries to seduce the blind man; James, a cheerful soul who is in the advanced stages of AIDS; and Buzz, a fan of traditional Broadway musicals who is dealing with his own HIV-positive status. Written by Dennis Lewis
The premise sounds great but the promise is never fulfilled. Terrence McNally's Tony Award-winning hit about a cluster of gay male friends who gather several times one summer at a Victorian house on the bank of a rural lake never quite measures up (at least on film) as anything particularly profound. The story traces a history of infighting and changing relationships within the group, with the shock of AIDS slowly pushing everyone toward greater closeness and honesty. But instead of making an impact, so much of the film is trivial: dinner conversations are banal, tantrums are tedious, genitals are a little too overexposed. The two best and most familiar actors in the piece, Jason Alexander and John Glover, ironically play the most cliché-ridden characters. Still, Glover--who portrays British twin brothers who could not be more different from one another--is a very good reason to see this film. --Tom Keogh
Edition Details
Release Date 5/4/2004
Packaging Keep Case
Screen Ratio 1.85:1
Subtitles English; Spanish
Audio Tracks ENGLISH: Dolby Digital Stereo [CC]
Layers Single Side, Single Layer
No. of Discs/Tapes 1
Personal Details
Purchase Date 2/9/2007
Location Personal Library
Owner Deitz
Store Amazon.com
Purchase Price $17.99
Condition New
Tags HIV/AIDS
Links + Review: NY Times of Play
± Review: Roger Ebert
Amazon US
IMDB
DVD Empire
Movie Collector Core
TheMovieDb.org

Features
Features Not Specified
References
Streaming, VoD Not Found
Lists ‡ 175 Essential Films for GLBT Viewers from Advocate (6/23/2014)

Notes
This movie was produced in 1997 based on Terrence McNally's 1997/98 Tony award winning play of the same name -- I did not see the play, and purchased the DVD for my collection in 2007 -- I did not watch the movie until 2016 as I suspected it might bring back memories that were too painful -- And indeed, viewing it was painful, but not in the way I expected -- It's about eight mostly upper-middle-class gay men, most of them in their early middle age, in the time of AIDS plague -- But the story is not about the love, valour and compassion I experienced back at the height of those terrible days when gay men, my friends and sons of mothers and fathers, were dying from a mysterious plague -- Instead the movie's protagonists are about as white and bourgeois as you can get -- To me they were (as as one review commented) "cartoon characters -- And not very nice ones -- Every distasteful stereotype is there" -- The folks I knew back then were not partying at luxurious country homes by a lakeside; they were struggling without jobs, housing, often dependent on hostile public social services, and sometimes ostrocized from their families and even their gay friends -- It was painful to me that such a prominent playwright as Terrence McNally should have glorified these delettants by the lake -- And even more painful that the public, including the gay public, seems to have bought it -- A friend said to me: "You should net be surprised -- The people by the lake are probably the only people McNally knows, he is, after all, a creature of the Hamptons and NY elite".